5.4 Biology Reform Projects

Biology education in the United States has been influenced to the greatest degree (aside from the socio-political- cultural issues of the evolution-creation science debate) by the Biological Sciences Curriculum Study (BSCS) than by another force or group. The BSCS was organized in 1959 at the University of Colorado. It is still as active as a curriculum force in science education today, with headquarters in Colorado Springs, Colorado.

The BSCS developed three approaches and separate curricula for the high school biology program. The BSCS developed two organizational structures that were used to give direction to the three approaches to biology. BSCS, according to William Mayer identified seven levels of organization as follows:

1. The molecular level

2. The cellular level

3. The organ and tissue level

4. The organismic level

5. The population level

6. The community level

7. The world biome level

The three versions of BSCS that were developed were organized around three of the above levels, and according to Mayer, "in order not to prejudice prospective users for or against any one of the three approaches, there were no descriptive titles: rather, the three texts were designated by color." The versions and their "level of organization," are as follows:

BSCS Blue Version: (Molecular) Biological Sciences: Molecules to Man

BSCS Yellow Version: (Cell) Biological Science: An Inquiry into Life

BSCS Green Version: (World biome) Biological Science: An Ecological Approach

BSCS materials were also organized around a set of unifying themes---"the characteristics and concepts that provide the most comprehensive and reliable knowledge of living things known to modern science." The unifying themes were identified as follows:

  1. Change of living things through time: evolution.
  2. Diversity of type and unity of pattern in living things.
  3. The genetic continuity of life.
  4. The complementarity of organism and environment.
  5. The biological roots of behavior.
  6. The complementarity of structure and function.
  7. Regulation and homeostasis: preservation of life in the face of change.
  8. Science as enquiry.
  9. The history of biological concepts.

Hurd points out that the first five unifying themes were used to organize the content in each version, themes 8 and 9 refer to the internal structure of biology, and themes 6 and 7 refer to content and structure.

The three versions of BSCS (See the chart below) impacted high school biology enormously. Shymansky, Kyle, and Alport reported that there was more research data available on the BSCS programs than any other new curriculum project. BSCS programs compared very favorably against traditional biology courses. With the exception of physics, the new biology programs "showed the greatest gains across all criteria measured," (achievement, perceptions, process skills, analytic skills).

BSCS Yellow, Blue, and Green Curricula

Yellow Version

Biological Science: An Inquiry into Life

Blue Version

Biological Science: Molecules to Man

Green Version

Biological Science: An Ecological Approach

• Unity: Life from life, basic structure and functions, living chemistry, the physiology and reproduction of cells, and the heredity materials.

• Diversity: viruses, bacteria, important small organisms, molds, yeasts and mushrooms, the trend toward complexity, the land turns green, photosynthesis, stems and roots.

• Continuity: patterns of heredity, the chromosome theory of heredity, Darwinian evolution, the mechanisms of evolution and the cultural evolution of man.

• Interaction: a population out of balance, a perspective of time and life: molecules to man.

• Biology, the Interaction of Facts and Ideas: science as inquiry, the variety of living things, conflicting views on the means of evolution, the origin of living things.

• Evolution of Life Processes: forerunners of life, chemical energy for life, light as energy for life, and life with oxygen.

• The Evolution of the Cell: master molecules, the biological code, the cell theory.

• Multicellular Organisms: New Individuals: multicellular organism, reproduction, and development.

• Multicellular Organisms: Genetic Continuity: patterns of heredity, genes and chromosomes, the origin of species.

• Multicellular Organisms: Energy Utilization: transport, respiratory, digestive and excretory systems.

• Multicellular Organisms: Unifying Systems: regulatory, nervous, skeletal and muscular systems, the organism and behavior.

• Higher Levels of Organization: human species, populations, societies and communities.

• The World of Life: The web of life, individuals and populations, communities and ecosystems.

• Diversity Among Living Things: Animals, plants, protists.

• Patterns in the Biosphere: Patterns of life in the microscopic world, on land, in the water, in the past.

• Within the Individual Organism: The cell, bioenergetics, the functioning cell, the functioning animal, behavior.

• Continuity of the Biosphere: reproduction, heredity, evolution.

•Man and the Biosphere: The human animal, man in the web of life.